Shootings in Paris

Discussion in 'General Discussion' started by Barry Haynes, Nov 13, 2015.

  1. Poptop2

    Poptop2 Administrator

    Not quite the way I would see that tbh. A person upholding law and order in his own land and simply protecting our basic life is noble thing - It is also the same with our soldiers. Why though do we have to go around the world killing people in the name of that society? Defend it yes, create and perpetuate war in the name of freedom I reserve the right to disagree!
     
    vanorak likes this.
  2. Fair one.
    Saying that, I wouldn't trust the plebs to invade their own canteen let alone a foreign land.
     
    zed and Poptop2 like this.
  3. Why is it the same? Surely anyone who joined the services in recent years (well almost anytime in history) would have realised that if the Marmite hit the fan then they would be sent overseas.
     
    fritt and chad like this.
  4. Poptop2

    Poptop2 Administrator

    I think you are trying to get me to say something about our armed forces. I think defending our land is fair and right. I think perpetuating war in another country is wrong. The armed forces do as the government bid. A General does as he is told. A soldier does as he is ordered. A few of my cousins have served in Afghanistan recently and since leaving the army have asked why they were there and what good it did. I have no simple answer. I do however have answers that are complex and disheartening. The short of it is - greed and power.
     
    vanorak likes this.
  5. Moons

    Moons Supporter

    The fact that it's called The Ministry Of Defence is weird isn't it.

    We went into countries under a knowing lie to 'defend' who exactly?
     
    vanorak and Poptop2 like this.
  6. I may be somewhat naïve about the underlying factors of conflict but I didn't realise there was soo little support or understanding for at least attempting to keep the wolves from the door. Its all done in your name people whether you like it or not and its that same nice bloke you say your proud of that wears the uniform that delivers the deeds your ashamed of.
     
    Faust, oscar, chad and 1 other person like this.
  7. Zed

    Zed Gradually getting grumpier

    That's easy, ye olde not-quite-saying-what-it-really-means - "British Interests".
     
  8. chad and zed like this.
  9. Poptop2

    Poptop2 Administrator

    Do you really believe that C? I know what you are saying and yes of course the people in our forces deserve our full support. It isn't the armed forces I don't trust.It's the fact we have people in charge of the armed forces and our country that I do not trust that we should be concerned about. The lies we were told to enter Iraq were appalling and a gross misuse of the nations trust!
     
    vanorak likes this.
  10. chad, zed and Pickles like this.
  11. Yes (No) ... I spent a couple of months in 1994 patrolling off the coast supporting the work of the army etc.
     
    Last edited: Nov 17, 2015
    chad and Poptop2 like this.
  12. Tuesday wildchild

    Tuesday wildchild I'm a circle!

    They can recruit all them @Baysearcher sacked early in the year. ;)
     
    Last edited: Nov 17, 2015
    Poptop2 likes this.
  13. Poptop2

    Poptop2 Administrator

    A United nations operation under the banner of policing forced through by the Americans who feared anything ex communist.
     
  14. Moons

    Moons Supporter

    ?

    I don't understand your point.

    All conflicts are perpetuated by two entities that nominate 'defence' as their primary motive, and obsesses over the oppositions act of attack.

    The fact that our military are deployed on humanitarian grounds on occasion is not relevant.

    On the one hand people want us to damn acts of aggression by people not playing by the rules, and damn their leaders for being myopic....and question it all, yet we aren't to turn introspectively on ourselves on occasion? How does this give us any moral or intellectual higher ground?

    We can't understand them if we don't understand us surely?

    Questioning that is not disloyalty or lacking support, it's not cowardice or being a do gooder....its recognising that pretty much all conflicts are resolved by communication and understanding...that is not achievable if you enter negotiations with the sole stance that you are cleaner than clean.

    We all have our point of tolerance, that yours has been breached doesn't mean ours is incorrect...I'm sure in other circumstances it's viceversa.

    The failure, well documented, at a higher level to deal with this is not damming on our military, it's a tragedy. The slaughter of innocents is nothing short of a tragedy too, the method a disgrace.


    The only winners in conflicts are the people with vested interests in weapons manufacture...the sole winners. We dealt with Middle East equitably for years...then we started meddling because western corporations wanted to cut deals that weren't equitable and 'sorted' it by mostly devious means.

    That that comes home to roost is expected, if not palatable.

    I said months ago that ISIS were the new nazis....we've sat on our hands in the meantime.

    How are there pictures of ISIS fighters driving year old US and Japanese pick up trucks? Whose supplying them with Internet access? Where's the food coming from? How are they seemingly living well in occupied areas? How are the buses running on time as it were?

    There a lot of business being cut with this 'enemy' day in day out...
     
    vanorak likes this.
  15. Moons

    Moons Supporter

    Yes, my older brother was deployed there as part of the UN Ifor force.

    No, no oil.
     
  16. Poptop2

    Poptop2 Administrator

    Oil!
     
  17. Poptop2

    Poptop2 Administrator

    The intervention in Bosnia was well overdue. There was a human disaster going on and mulsims were being slaughtered in their thousands. It was completely sanctioned by the now almost defunct UN. The same intervention in Rwanda was equally justified.

    One downside of the Bosnian intervention that should otherwise be applauded - James Blunt! ;)
     
    Moons likes this.
  18. Baysearcher

    Baysearcher [secret moderator]

    Love the way this bloody horrible event has culminated in an "I'm cleverer than you" thread on a poxy VW forum.
     
    mgbman and Dicky like this.
  19. Poptop2

    Poptop2 Administrator

    This is a bit harsh. It's how people deal with things.
     
    vanorak likes this.
  20. Baysearcher

    Baysearcher [secret moderator]

    It's not harsh at all.
    Read it as someone who hasn't got involved in the "Google" war and you'd see it differently.
     

Share This Page