..My engine's knocking noise...here we go again..

Discussion in 'Mech Tech' started by areksilverfish, May 26, 2014.

  1. areksilverfish

    areksilverfish Supporter

    Hi everyone!
    Well, after few weeks of thinking about my engine issues I have decided to drop it and strip it down...this morning :)
    To be honest I was expecting some horrors but hmm..here is what I found...
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    [​IMG]
    Well, need to add all the bearings/cam were new... I know it looks like it was running hot but could this cause all those bearings wear? please tell me your thoughts, suggestions?

    Cheers
    arek
     
  2. Razzyh

    Razzyh Supporter

    What engine?

    I'll guess T4 so maybe @Paul Weeding knows but I believe he is having 2 weeks holiday so maybe @zed knows?
     
  3. Remind me what you did when you rebuilt it the first time round!!

    Crank reground??
     
  4. areksilverfish

    areksilverfish Supporter

    No. It was very budget rebuild if you know what I mean ;-) The crank itself doesnt look bad really I only replaced main/cam bearings and camshaft/pushrods.. It looks like at the mo I was right suspecting rods/pins coz they seem to be worst/quite badly worn..it also looks like its been overheated whic
     
  5. MorkC68

    MorkC68 Administrator

    Did you measure the crank for wear and check the block's wear in the bearing journals
     
  6. That cam is in a bad way if it's new, what mileage was on it? My guess is you had a failed oil pump, blocked galleries, ran it with no oil, or the bearings you installed were the wrong size. Did you install new lifters with the cam and break it in then run it in?

    The heating on the bearings makes it look like it was elliptic hence me asking were the bearings the correct size. Out of interests, does it look anywhere on the case bearing saddles like the bearing numbers have been stamped into the case? Could point to a bent crank/worn out case.
    :)
    :)
     
  7. areksilverfish

    areksilverfish Supporter

    Sorry guys...its my boody mobile grrr...unfortunately Im struggling to write anything on my comp too :(
    Anyways back to subject... the motor was overheated probably as it was really bad timed (my fault)...
    I didn't really measure anything just had a good look/touch that was it... I did realise it was not done properly at the time but was really pushed to get it running asap... The crank still looks ok but I know it needs to checked this time.. Any advice how to do it please and where exactly?
     
  8. MorkC68

    MorkC68 Administrator

    this may have been the start of your problems, Im far from knowledgeable but trying to learn too..measure, measure and measure again is the key, if there was any slight discrepancy between the actual crank measurements and the bearings you replaced, it could have meant there was play from the word go.

    All of the bearing locations on the crank will need measuring with a vernier as will the journals on the case..do this first and post up here & we can help you move forward
     
  9. areksilverfish

    areksilverfish Supporter

    Nope..there no stamps of bearing number anywhere onto case... I checked it...in fact this motor has apx 180k kms on it so its not too bad for 35 years old...also pending all its life in Germany it looks like its been properly serviced at the time.. I know its does not mean anything but... The cam was nearly new the lifter brand new from CBs... The fact is also there was a problem with oil pressure when it was cold...
     
  10. areksilverfish

    areksilverfish Supporter

    Yep..will try to measure everything tomz and will post it up here defo... Got to make sure this time everythings need to be done properly...
    BTW.. I remember I measured old mains and they turned out to be standards...I did break the cam in but it was badly timed..
     
  11. MorkC68

    MorkC68 Administrator

    if you pop any part numbers taken off the bearings up too, that will help.

    Im building a type 4 myself and am taking my time with it, Im recording any findings down on paper when the parts are removed then as Im cleaning and renovating, measuring again, if anything looks worn or damaged Im replacing with new!
     
  12. Looking at the centre main, it looks like the crank might have a slight bend in it...

    Also, it is worth noting that all of the builds that I've had come through, not one has had a crank within its tolerance... so everything is getting a 0.25 grind - That's mains, and rod big ends.

    Cases are a real 50/50 as to whether they need a line bore... Most you get are on the edge of tolerance, usually just within, others are just over spec...

    Can you confirm the cam was new or used? Did you use new lifters with it if it was used, or lifters that came with the cam?
     
  13. areksilverfish

    areksilverfish Supporter

    The cam wasnt brand new however it was not used just spent abit of time in my mates shed..the lifters bought brand new from CB Performance in US.. I put them into the block and did break in for 15-20 mins...
    BTW lifters still look like new...
     
  14. MorkC68

    MorkC68 Administrator

    is that because of the wear pattern on the bearing face (Im curious & using the info for my build)
     
  15. Yes, the wear pattern looks like the crank was moving in an elliptical pattern, suggests wrong sized bearings, worn case or bent crank.
    :)
     
  16. I'd bin the cam and bearings, have the crank checked and ground if needed, looks fubar to me though
    :)
     
  17. MorkC68

    MorkC68 Administrator

    Cheers for replying - much appreciated! Ill make sure I check & double check all our measurements before we order bearings etc!
     
  18. What's wrong with the cam ? Is this not a case of shot big ends ?
     
  19. 77 Westy

    77 Westy Supporter

    The photograph isn’t great but I can’t see anything wrong with the cam, it just looks like it’s had a break in run. Can’t see anything wrong with the main bearing journals either but the crank needs to be inspected and measured properly (a Vernier measurement would indicate if the crank has had a regrind).

    In my opinion the bearing damage is probably due to low oil pressure or the wrong size bearings resulting in low oil pressure. The crank could also be a bent - that’s why it needs to be inspected.
     
  20. areksilverfish

    areksilverfish Supporter

    Hi,
    Thanks guys.. Much appreciated for any help:) Well been busy so didnt have much time for the bus..anyway at first sight looks like there is indeed a bad/wrong/worn? bearings as they are pretty loose on the crank..all of them.. This indicates that I made mistake at measuring the crank/old bearings.. Well learning hard way.. Will check them properly when get the tool I ordered so will let you know.. But yes you right! There was a problem with low oil pressure..the question now is what caused that? Could have been quite few things really... The cam itself well I think too is absolutely fine as the lifters are.. It might be that poor pic.. Anyway big thanks again as at the time I can count on you only:)
     

Share This Page