Would you like a second referendum

Discussion in 'General Discussion' started by jivedubbin, Jan 15, 2019.

?

Would you like a second referendum

  1. Yes

    13 vote(s)
    27.7%
  2. No

    34 vote(s)
    72.3%
  1. Poptop2

    Poptop2 Administrator

    I think the vote amounted to asking parliament to take the UK out of the EU. Legally it has to go through parliament. That was always the sticking point no matter which way the vote went. You’re now seeing politics and politicians for what it really is.

    This has been so polarising that unlike the run of the mill elections you can’t vote, shrug your shoulders and ignore them.

    Not you personally, all of us!
     
  2. Barry Haynes

    Barry Haynes I dance in leopard skin mankini’s

    To be honest It didn’t look very promising when I arrived at the lake so to get one of the new stockies was a real bonus, I was very chuffed :thumbsup:
     
    Pony, matty and mgbman like this.
  3. I’d go further. I believe this is a pivotal point in Uk history. A few hundred MPs believe that their opinions and their needs count for more than the 17million voters opinion given at the ballot box. If brexit is stopped by those MPs then that’s nothing short of treason, it’s a coup. It’s a seizure of power from the people to the so called elite.

    My opinion then is that the will of the people from a democratic vote must prevail and the people will need to remove these insurgents by any means necessary.
     
    Pudelwagen and mgbman like this.
  4. Having a referendum is a fairly recent thing and the first British referendum was held in 1975, also to do with the EU or EEC as it was known then. At that time it was about joining the EEC and the country and political parties were split and unsure about it then.

    This latest referendum on leaving the EU was similarly divided and won on a small margin. Clearly as a nation we still have mixed feelings about the EU some 43 years later.

    The EU had an opportunity with Cameron to make changes which would have kept us in the EU but on new terms. The opportunity was thrown away and put our government in a difficult position where we were not happy with the EU rules imposed on us and we could not change them, so the only way was to divorce.

    Hence the referendum, this time to leave what we joined back in 1975.
     
    Ian Jones likes this.
  5. I remember back in the 1970's, we were a struggling young family surrounded by doom and gloom with industrial unrest, strikes, violence, power cuts, fuel shortages, 3 day working week, high inflation, high interest rates and more, there seemed to be no way out of the pain. Joining the EEC seemed a positive and hopeful step. But we couldn't wait for the promised good times and as a family we moved to New Zealand in the hope of a better life, which it was for a time, until the effects of the EEC began to bite.

    Britain was now tied in to Europe and we were paying big money to support French farmers and German industry. We were buying European produce which we were subsidising and turned our backs on our allies New Zealand and Australia for their lamb, cheese and butter and more which impacted their economies badly.

    British industry went into decline as we moved to a so called 'services' economy. Our farmers could not produce food in competition with European subsidies so our farmers and countryside changed drastically. The subsidies produced gluts of food and wine lakes which had to be thrown away, but the French farmers still got their money.

    The French farmers have now become a force to be reckoned with and won't give up their subsidies without a fight.

    All of the concerns raised back in 1975 have come about and now we are stuck in this mess trying to get out.
     
  6. mikedjames

    mikedjames Supporter

    With a general election you get another chance every few years to continue the dialogue,and change back if the vote says so.

    Brexit is different. One vote and you are out or at the back of the queue to get back in a generation later.

    I have already lost one job because of Brexit.. because of uncertainty over Brexit the job moved to Europe.

    I do not believe the EU is perfect but at heart it is a democracy. Inside it we can vote to change.
    Out of the EU we will only able to obey the rules that will be enforced by the EU which we will have no right to change , if we want to trade with it or work with it.
    So go for Remain but be awkward customers within the union.
     
    nobody likes this.
  7. Baysearcher

    Baysearcher [secret moderator]

    There's some knob on the BBC at the moment banging on about the need for a general election. The interviewer asked 1 very simple question: "Would labour voters be voting for a Leave or Remain party?"
    He couldn't answer.
    Laughable.
     
  8. Do you really believe that. Look what happened when Cameron asked for some change.
     
    Baysearcher, Pudelwagen and mgbman like this.
  9. Inside it we can vote to change?

    No we can't, that's the problem we have with the EU.

    The EU is dominated by the Germans and they won't agree with anything we say. They want to be the big boys and control the other member states.

    They are playing games with us and now suggesting they are open to more talks.
     
  10. The problem with the EU is that fundamentally it isn’t a democracy. When was the last time you were given a vote on whether you like Donald tusk or junkers? You haven’t been, you won’t be, because it’s a club of self serving unelected and non removable bureaucrats. They exist to protect their own jobs and those of their paymasters.

    Look at the shambles of the EU accounts. They literally can’t tell you where they are spending your money. Try that with HMRC and see if you get away with it. They can cos they are above the law. Cos they set the laws. Not your elected government which you can rightly vote to change.
     
    Faust, Lord Congi, art b and 3 others like this.
  11. So we have decided that we don't want a second referendum ,

    Thank you for your votes ,I thought it might be a good idea just to see how the lay of the land was .
     
    Ermintrude likes this.
  12. x
     
  13. bernjb56

    bernjb56 Supporter

    I haven’t voted :eek:
     
  14. Baysearcher

    Baysearcher [secret moderator]

    13 people who don't agree with the basics of democracy.
     
  15. Poptop2

    Poptop2 Administrator

    The point is, we have to go through the parliamentary process. Every MP has his/her own constituents to face and a lot of people are asking for clarity. That clarity is coming slowly and the truth about Brexit and the implications seem, err - not quite how it was portrayed.

    I was being nice to the brexiteers then!

    I'll give you something to laugh at now!

    [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Jan 18, 2019
  16. Baysearcher

    Baysearcher [secret moderator]

    When and why did this get locked?
     
    Bhubesi and Lord Congi like this.
  17. Poptop2

    Poptop2 Administrator

    No idea!
     
  18. Baysearcher

    Baysearcher [secret moderator]

  19. bernjb56

    bernjb56 Supporter

    jivedubbin likes this.
  20. Baysearcher

    Baysearcher [secret moderator]

    Seems a bit overkill. For the first time in living memory a political thread was actually going quite well!
     

Share This Page