Injecting a sense of uncertainty

Discussion in 'Mech Tech' started by Chrisd, Feb 28, 2021.

  1. Chrisd

    Chrisd Supporter

    Cheers guys. Excluding reliability for a bit, what performance difference would a new system have over original working system?

    Fuel, mapping (is that even possible on the original ECU?), torque range etc

    I'm hoovering up knowledge, so don't be shy :D.
     
    iblaze likes this.
  2. The original ecu is from a different era. I'd doubt it has any "brains", so no mapping or anything.
     
  3. Chrisd

    Chrisd Supporter

    I thought not, but good to get that confirmation. My slight worry with the Californian version ECU that I have, is that it is set up with the assumption of some recirculated exhaust from the exhaust gas recirculation EGR. I understand that this could mean that without the extra hydrocarbons, it might run lean?
     
  4. No idea.

    If you were updating the FI system, you wouldn't use an original ECU anyway. Things have moved on!
     
    lhu1281 and Chrisd like this.
  5. FI and carb engines use different cams . A modern ECU is tuned to your engine plus it uses a lamda sensor to get the AFR perfect along with crank fire trigger to do away with distributor . Modern Coil per plug plus it’s infinitely more tunable will make more power plus 100% more reliable
     
    Chrisd likes this.
  6. Chrisd

    Chrisd Supporter

    OK, so not much then :D

    My engine was originally an FI and that's why I'm toying with the idea of converting it back and.collecting the old.parts.

    I should have asked this question a couple of years.ago...doh

    Hmmm now what to do without spending stupid money?
     
  7. mikedjames

    mikedjames Supporter

    Exhaust gas is being used in EGR as inert gas so its really added to make idle cleaner by being able to idle at the same speed while burning less fuel.

    The brains of a stock EFI is all in that resistor track with its laser trimmed voltage ratios hooked up to the air damped heavy weighted flap in the AFM..


    Modern EFI can use just about any combination of sensors to provide injector control. Not all of them are as perfect as any other.
    Adding a throttle position sensor, and a manifold air pressure sensor or a mass air flow sensor, and picking up a distributor points pulse would be enough to drive a Speeduino ECU or a MegaSquirt ECU.

    Things like lambda sensors are great for tuning but in fact you could set the whole thing up without them in the EFI control loop, although you would really still need one for checking it works properly
     
  8. why does every modern car have a lambda sensor if it’s not needed then ? The only sensor I’m not running is a knock sensor , and I would if it was an easy do .
     
  9. mikedjames

    mikedjames Supporter

    For adjustment .. when at a steady state. But when you are accelerating , certainly the well documented ECUs go go open loop because of the time lag between the engine and the sensor.
    And the lambda sensors are also used to make sure the catalytic converter is fed enough fuel to keep the fires burning..

    After all the stock EFI did not have a lambda sensor just an analog computer controlling the injectors triggered by the ignition and controlled by the AFM flap and the angle to voltage map created by the laser trimmed resistors..

    And the CIS (K-Jet) just has an air flap controlling needle valves feeding the injectors, with the inertia and overshoot of the heavy balanced flap mechanism taking over the job of feeding more fuel on acceleration.
     

  10. That’s why I’ve gone all new and modern I can’t be arsed with worn out second hand parts from the 70s . Populate your tables on your laptop and drive
     
    Lasty likes this.
  11. Chrisd

    Chrisd Supporter

    Some good food for thought so thanks peeps.

    As I have most of the original FI parts, I hope to build a bench engine mount and sometime in the future drop the engine, swap the Weber's to the FI system and see how it works on the bench for starters. I'm not adverse to change, hence my questions but I do wonder if once you change one thing do you butt up against the characteristics of the next item in the old system and start a cascade of change?

    With that in mind, what one part of a standard FI kit would you change that would make a marked difference? I do worry about the AFM, but that's because I know a bit about it, but am I thinking about the wrong link in the chain.
     
  12. Chrisd

    Chrisd Supporter

    This is obviously a slow burn project!

    Question for the engineers and/or FI gurus amongst us; are the various vacuum pipes reinforced in any way? I want to buy some lengths of flexible pipes and the shops I've found have thick wall silicon pipes but don't mention reinforcement.

    I suspect they are fine, but I thought I'd check.

    Thanks.
     
    Last edited: May 23, 2025
  13. mikedjames

    mikedjames Supporter

    Unless it states for vacuum use, and they have some reinforcement against what can be crushing pressures of 0.7 bar, all those lovely silicone hoses are just decorations.
    Everything downstream of the throttle body just sucks, especially when you suddenly let off at WOT.

    Using metal tubes with short silicone joiners is another approach, or even what I started doing when my FI was going to be a K-Jet , making curved tube shapes out of aluminium sheet with tin snips pop riveted and then wrapping them in faired and painted epoxy glass laminate to seal and stiffen them, joining with short sections of rubber hose.

    I was just looking at Demon Tweeks and the wide range of application specific double reinforced inlet manifold silicone pipes. All precisely correct for one particular engine.
     
    Last edited: May 24, 2025
    Chrisd likes this.
  14. vinnyboy

    vinnyboy Supporter

    Almost every modern diesel engine has vacuum operated items such as egr coolers, turbo actuators etc. some have flexible hose only. Many use hard plastic/ metal pipe with rubber elbows at each end. This should be readily available on the roll
     
    Chrisd likes this.
  15. Chrisd

    Chrisd Supporter

  16. mikedjames

    mikedjames Supporter

  17. Should be ok for small bore vacuum hoses (say 4mm ID). The walls aren't reinforced, but are quite thick. I've got them on my engine for the dissy vacuum hose (from the same company).

    For bigger stuff, say 13mm ID for the brake servo, reinforced hose is better..
     
    Chrisd likes this.
  18. Chrisd

    Chrisd Supporter

    The hose sizes (internal diameter) go from 4.5mm to 22mm.
     
  19. 22mm will need reinforcment if they're a vacuum hose. Try Car Builder Solutions (where I got my servo hose from).
     
    Chrisd likes this.
  20. DamonW

    DamonW Supporter

    IMG_5541.jpeg I bought the whole kit from German supply Canada and all cut to correct lengths with all the right pieces including elbows and T pieces etc
    Part NumberQtyItemUnit PriceTOTAL
    GS 102 Kit1Fuel Hose Kit Fuel Injected Bus '75-'79, Vanagon 2.0l
    Options:
    Year:
    78-79
    $CAD162.00 $CAD162.00
    N 20 357 1 50X91Fuel Tank Vapour Recovery Hose Kit Bus '78-'79$CAD25.00 $CAD25.00
    GS 109L1EGR Block-off Plate Large Engine Cover Bus '74-'79 Vanagon '80-'83$CAD12.00 $CAD12.00
    039 133 2414Intake Manifold Sleeve Bus '75-'79, Vanagon '80-'85$CAD7.00 $CAD28.00
    GS 106 Kit1Vacuum Hose Kit Fuel Injected Bus '75-'79, Vanagon '80-'83.5
    Options:
    Year:
    '76-'79
    Model:
    Bus
    transmission:
    Manual Transmission
    hoses:
    No Decel Hoses
     
    Chrisd likes this.

Share This Page