Starter motor (modern car)

Discussion in 'Mech Tech' started by volkswombat, Feb 24, 2019.

  1. Hellooooo
    This is on a 2011 Volvo V50 diesel.

    3 weeks ago the starter went, (car started in morning but made a screechy noise for about 30 secs after starting, then tried to start later on and was totally dead) RAC towed me to a local rac approved garage who fitted a new one.

    On Friday (on holiday in lakes) starter did the same thing (noise this time was horrific, lasted about 5 mins and mega burning smell)
    Thus was put down to jolly bad luck, and the RAC took me to RAC approved garage in Keswick and paid for another new starter to be fitted.

    Today, the starter has started screeching after engine starts, it's still starting the car but Im expecting it to burn out or fail very soon.....

    So, can't be just be bad luck.
    What underlying issue would be causing starters to self destruct?
     
  2. Sticking solonoid??
     
  3. Sounds like you have a short somewhere that garages havnt picked up ?
     
  4. Is that a separate part then , that wouldn't be replaced with a new starter?

    Sorry, I'm a bit fick wiv modern engines ......!
     
  5. Would a short not break the starter the first time it was used though?
     
  6. matty

    matty Supporter

    Worn teeth on the flywheel will jam the starter on
     
  7. Sounds like the pinion’s not disengaging and the enginee’s driving the starter round. Had the same on my old Golf. New starter time!
     
  8. Got RAC out again, he also said worn flywheel teeth,
     
  9. That sounds most unlikely to me. Was this RAC guy a "Young Person"?

    I'd start by replacing the starter.
     
  10. This is it's 2nd new starter in 3 weeks....
     
  11. matty

    matty Supporter

    He has this is his 2rd in in 2 weeks
     
  12. davidoft

    davidoft Sponsor

    Either the starter is sticking oooorrrr the ignition switch isnt returning, always get the original starter motor tested before condemning it
     
    Dubs and snotty like this.
  13. Dubs

    Dubs Sponsor supporter extraordinaire

    I don't know if it's possible on a modern motor, but I have seen a bay that had a dodgy ignition switch, that would sometimes not flick fully back after starting, causing the starter to stay engaged with the flywheel. Have a look at the old starter and see if the teeth are chewed up.
     
  14. davidoft

    davidoft Sponsor

    Is it push key start or turn key start ? Could be an ecu issue : o
     
  15. Yeah it's one of them new fangled "not a key" keys,
    Will get it to a garage in morn anyway
     
    davidoft likes this.
  16. Maybe stuck relay then!
     
  17. turns out the teeth on flywheel have pretty much disintegrated, so new dmf, ANOTHER new starter (that's no. 3), and because it's all apart , new clutch and slave cylinder because it would be stupid not to.
    So my bottom is now available for rogering to earn some cash
     
    art b and 3901mick like this.
  18. matty

    matty Supporter

    Do I win a prize
     
  19. You win the old flywheel, collection only though !
     
    snotty and matty like this.
  20. You win the bill.
     
    MrsVolkswombat, snotty and matty like this.

Share This Page