Your ideas on warnings etc

Discussion in 'General Discussion' started by hailfrank, Feb 11, 2013.

  1. hailfrank

    hailfrank Admin esq.

    So taking on board you would like clearer structure can we ask for your ideas in what should get a warning or a ban and also how long they last.


    ie
    swearing
    abuse towards another member
    spamming
    trolling
    racism,
    homophobia etc

    At the moment we pope rate a 3 strike you've gone system unless it warrants instant banning where myself and Horts will make the final call.

    Constructive comments wanted please
     
  2. personally i think bullying, racism, homophobia etc should be immediate bans as they are also illegal and any evidence of such should be kept by the mods in case of legal action. Just my thoughts.
    t'other stuff, not entirely sure what it is, except swearing and i can't make a call on that as i have a bit of a potty mouth at times :/
     
    paradox and 72wilma like this.
  3. Honky

    Honky Administrator

    To give this some context:

    With this system we are able to assign a score to warnings and if applicable an expiry period.

    So swearing might get 1 point with an expiry of 1 week.

    Abuse might get 5 points with an expiry of 2 months.

    Then we can assign measures based on the number of unexpired points.

    So for example, a user may get 9 active points which would result in a 3 month ban.

    Does that make sense?
     
  4. Case by case basis, But personally I don't think any of this is needed, Is all that's required is a little self moderation, and for people to grow up.

    Its a forum, its not even real life don't cha know.

    Nuff said.
     
  5. Poptop2

    Poptop2 Administrator

    i did suggest a sin bin when we were chatting on earlibay - perhaps a 3 strike system puts someone in a sin bin where they can view but not participate and maybe 5 strikes gets a ban - maybe put up a list of offences so as people can clearly see what we tolerate and what they have been " striked" for ?
     
  6. Baysearcher

    Baysearcher [secret moderator]

    Swearing: we're all adults. This should be left alone.
    Anything illegal: Ban
    Difference of opinion: see swearing.
     
    Top Banana Racing and Tiny-Pie like this.
  7. Zed

    Zed Gradually getting grumpier

    If you ban me for 3 months from totting up my **** slippages I don't think I'd come back again.
     
    kenregency likes this.
  8. dog

    dog Tea Boy

    but it wont be like that, the idea is that the users that occasionally break the rules will get warnings that expire before they tot up too many points, only the persistent ones will get a ban!
     
  9. Re swearing. The filter should pick these up. So you should only get warnings if you deliberately bypass it somehow.
     
    72wilma and lowie like this.
  10. dog

    dog Tea Boy

    good point!
     
  11. Agree we are all grown adults :rolleyes:
    I realy cant see the point in points system.
    However I do agree with gross misconduct being an immediate ban.
    As for a couple of swears I think that the mods can easily "Sheriff" this.
    Little bit like being back at school here lately :confused:
    Think we need to lift the mood a bit, dont you think ;)
     
  12. Baysearcher

    Baysearcher [secret moderator]

    Surely if there's a filter we can swear if we feel the need to?
     
  13. i agree. personally, if i got banned for dropping the odd b*****k hen i would probably take massive umbrage and not come back.

    i like the points/time thingy but i know i'd be in danger as i type as i speak with often a more than liberal dose of invectives (depending on subject matter). can i apologise now?
     
  14. Zed

    Zed Gradually getting grumpier

    ok
     
  15. Honky

    Honky Administrator

    Thats why we're asking for your thoughts.
     
  16. dog

    dog Tea Boy

    yes but people always find ways round it unfortunately
     
  17. Baysearcher

    Baysearcher [secret moderator]

    Personally I'd get rid of the filter then.
    This is after all a forum primarily for adults...
     
  18. i like the filter, it makes me laugh. keep it but just give a naughty point to one who is clever enough to get round it (that'll never be me!) :D
     
  19. the thing is there s the context of the swears isn’t there
    example your a right @hailfrank ban me please!
    or your a right @hailfrank ban me please! :):)
     
  20. and that must be taken into account surely
     

Share This Page